Important information about law review membership is below. Information about the Law Review is also available in the NYLS Student Handbook.
- Grade-On Selection and Invitations
- Write-On Selection
- Write-On Competition and Invitations
- Orientation and Membership Requirements
Instructions & Fact Pattern
Grade-On Selection and Invitations
The primary method of law review membership selection is based on a class rank requirement, calculated at the end of each academic year. Students who meet the grade-on requirements for Law Review membership are notified via their NYLS email address in late June or early July each year, following the close of the academic year. Grade-on membership is determined as follows:
- First-Year Students. The Law Review extends invitations to 1Ls who rank in the top 15% of their division at the end of their first year (i.e., completion of two semesters) at NYLS based on their cumulative GPA. Day division students selected on this basis will begin participation in the Law Review in August, at the start their 2L year. Evening division students who are accepted on this basis will not start their Law Review duties until August of the following year, after upon completion of four semesters at NYLS.
- Second-Year and Transfer Students. The Law Review extends invitations to upper-level students, including transfer students who have completed two semesters at NYLS, whose cumulative GPA based on four semesters of grades places them in the top 10% of their class. These students will begin participation in August, at the start of their 3L year.
Grade-On Invitations. Students who receive an invitation based on their class rank will be notified in late June or early July. Students who join based on their 1L grades will be required to join the Harlan Scholars program and affiliate with one of the school’s Harlan academic centers. Students who receive an invitation based on their second-year GPA will not be part of the Harlan Scholars program.
The Law Review is pleased to invite continuing students who are not extended membership invitations based on the grade-on criteria to participate in the annual Write-On Competition (described below), subject to the following limitations: evening students may participate in the Write-On Competition only if they have completed two academic years (four semesters) of law school and transfer students must complete two semesters at New York Law School in order to be eligible to participate. Students who are in the Comprehensive Curriculum Program (CCP) are eligible to participate after completion of two semesters of law school; CCP status does not affect students’ eligibility.
The competition requires students to demonstrate their writing and legal analysis skills by drafting a paper based on a problem that is developed by the Law Review. A write-on problem from a prior year is available to download here. The problem is designed to allow students to demonstrate their writing and analytical skills based on an analysis of a scholarly article, a series of cases, or other relevant law.
Members of the Law Review’s editorial board and its Faculty Publisher will review all submissions and extend membership invitations to those students whose papers exhibit excellent writing and analysis. All submissions are reviewed anonymously, and invitations are extended solely based on the merit of the written submission. There is no pre-determined number of students who will be invited to join the Law Review through the Write-On competition. Decisions of the Publisher are final. Due to the number of submissions, the Law Review is unable to provide feedback on students’ write-on papers following the end of the Write-On Competition.
The Write-On Competition and Invitations
Participants must submit their papers according to instructions that are included in the problem. In order to accommodate the participation of students who spend their summers outside of the New York City area, students located outside of New York City have in prior years had the option of submitting their papers by overnight mail delivery to be received by the Law Review no later than 5pm on Monday, the first business day after the competition ends, so long as the copy is postmarked by 5pm on Friday, the last day of the competition. Students using overnight delivery services are responsible for meeting any pick-up or drop-off deadlines and for planning ahead to account for delivery times associated with overnight delivery services and students (particularly those who will be overseas) are urged to research this information in advance. The Law Review does not extend the deadline for any reason, including because of the timing of or any problems with the delivery service, and will not consider hard copy submissions delivered after 5pm on Friday or any overnight submissions delivered after 5pm on Monday.
Historically, submissions have been limited to 3000 words. All submissions must contain footnotes in the current Bluebook (19th ed.) format. Full instructions and additional requirements are included with the problem.
Bluebook Training Sessions (Optional). In prior years, the NYLS Library has held optional citation workshops, which students may find helpful. Advance registration is required. Dates and times will be announced prior to the start of the competition.
Write-On Invitations. All students who are selected for membership on the Law Review as a result of the Write-On Competition will receive formal invitations during the week following the end of the competition. Students selected through the Write-On competition will not be part of the Harlan Scholars program. (Note that the Harlan centers allow students who are not in the formal scholars program to associate with the centers and participate in coursework and other activities and projects.)
Orientation and Membership Requirements
All students invited to join the Law Review (except evening students who just completed their first two semesters of law school and whose participation in Law Review will not begin until August 2014) are required to attend our Orientation in August. Orientation is typically held the week before fall classes start. All new members must be at the law school all day on the first day (Monday) of Orientation, including those students in the evening division. Evening students are required to attend evening sessions for the remainder of the week. All Law Review members are required to take either the day or evening section of “Legal Scholarship” during the fall semester. Other requirements will be explained during Orientation.
For general inquiries, please email Managing Editor Alexandra Spina at firstname.lastname@example.org. For questions relating to membership requirements and the Write-On Competition, please contact Professor Michelle Zierler, faculty publisher, at email@example.com or 212-431-2330.